How do you answer a peer review question?

How do you answer a peer review question?

Begin with a letter to the managing editor and reviewers in which you thank them for their constructive criticism (even if it wasn't helpful) and state that you feel you have addressed all suggestions. If you've made any significant modifications, a line or two here is an excellent place to mention them. You can also include a brief explanation of what you changed and why.

If you are asked to prepare a revision in response to the comments, do so carefully, making sure that you have addressed all concerns raised by the reviewers. If you cannot address all concerns, explain why. For major issues that could affect the overall rating, such as serious problems with scientific logic or analysis, we will give you the opportunity to explain your position in a new review. The goal is not to get everything right the first time around but rather to come as close as possible without fixing anything significant. So if you make some small errors or forget something important, that's okay as long as you clearly acknowledge these omissions in your next round of reviews.

Finally, be sure to send us a copy of the revised paper along with the list of reviews, so we know how much work went into it.

How do you respond to a paper review?

What to say in response to reviewers

  1. Have a clear structure.
  2. Start with a kind intro thanking editor and reviewers.
  3. Be precise and respond to every single comment.
  4. Challenge the reviewers, if need be.
  5. Show some ‘blood’
  6. Exploit differences between reviewers to your benefit.
  7. Incorporate most, if not all of the additional literature the reviewers suggest.

How do you respond to a peer reviewer's comment?

Responding to reviewer feedback

  1. Begin by thanking the reviewer for taking the time to assess your manuscript.
  2. Then, specify that you’ve addressed all the concerns they raised.
  3. List all the reviewer’s comments and your answer to each one.
  4. Avoid giving yes or no answers.

How do you write a response to a review?

Ten easy guidelines for responding to reviewers:

  1. Provide an overview, then quote the full set of reviews.
  2. Be polite and respectful of all reviewers.
  3. Accept the blame.
  4. Make the response self-contained.
  5. Respond to every point raised by the reviewer.

How do you respond to a peer review?

Receiving and Responding to Peer Review Feedback

  1. Start a list of essential vs. unessential requests to prioritize your work.
  2. Decide whether you’ll need time to conduct additional experiments.
  3. Make sure you have a system for responding to each comment, and demonstrating your changes.
  4. Don’t ignore any comments.

How do you respond to a comment review?

When possible, provide a "yes" or "no" response. If the reviewer is accurate, include it in your response. Your aim is to demonstrate to the reviewer that you took their feedback seriously, and you should promptly communicate what you did in response to their criticism. Avoid giving lengthy explanations for your responses; instead, focus on the main points that can be addressed by revision.

For example: "Yes, I would like to use these examples in my essay." Or, "No, those are incorrect assumptions about my topic." If you feel like it's necessary to elaborate further, then you're going overboard with your response. The point of a review comment is not only to tell you how you can improve your work, but also to help others who may want to write similar papers in the future. So make sure that your response is clear and concise without being too short or long.

If you have an opinion on the accuracy of the criticism, then express this too. For example: "I disagree with his/her conclusion because data from study X support statement Y." Be careful not to get drawn into a debate with another user though - if you feel like it's off topic then just ignore it. The aim of a review comment is simply to let you know how you can improve your work, so don't waste time responding to comments that won't help you reach that goal.

How do you respond to peer feedback?

Receiving and Responding to Peer Review Feedback

  1. Start a list of essential vs. unessential requests to prioritize your work.
  2. Decide whether you’ll need time to conduct additional experiments. Don’t shy away from providing additional data.
  3. Make sure you have a system for responding to each comment, and demonstrating your changes.
  4. Don’t ignore any comments.

How do you write a review report?

Begin your review with a succinct overview of the paper's key themes, both for the editor's benefit and to ensure that you understand the material. — Next, assess the work's quality. Follow the sections of the reviewer's report form to provide assessments and comments on each of the publishing criteria. Finally, conclude by summarizing your overall impression of the manuscript.

To start, consider how well written is the paper? Does it read smoothly without too many errors? Are there any spelling or grammar mistakes? If so, you should probably mention them here!

After reading the article, think about its significance. Is it relevant to current research? Would others be interested in reading it? If so, why not try to explain this within your review?

Finally, give your opinion on whether the paper is worth publishing in your journal. Do you think it will contribute useful information to the field? Is it written clearly enough? Can you follow the arguments made in the paper? If not, what changes could be made to make it more accessible?

Of course, these are just some ideas of how to write a review report! You should feel free to come up with your own style guide for writing reviews.

As you can see, writing a review report is not as easy as it may seem at first glance!

About Article Author

Larry Muller

Larry Muller is a freelance content writer who has been writing for over 5 years. He loves to write about all sorts of topics, from personal development to eco-friendly tips. Larry can write about anything because he constantly keeps himself updated with the latest trends in the world of publishing.

Related posts