The distinction between a response paper and a review is that a reaction paper contains a commentary, personal reaction, perspective or stance on a subject. A review, on the other hand, synthesizes the issue and is subjective in character. It provides an overview of several topics within its field of interest.
Both reaction papers and reviews can be written as single articles or divided into sections. However, while a review may use subheadings to organize its content, a reaction paper should be written in an unstructured manner with no outline or preconceived idea of how it will flow. In addition, reviews are generally longer than reaction papers; usually between 3,000 and 5,000 words whereas reaction papers are typically under 2,000 words.
As you write your reaction paper, keep in mind that it is an independent piece of work that adds something new to the literature. You should not assume any knowledge about the topic beyond what can be found in the assignment instructions. Use data from different sources when possible, avoid repeating facts that are given in the assignment notes, and try not to copy/paste from other papers.
1 What are the main ideas being presented in the article?
The distinction between a diary and a reaction paper is that a diary is a location where you write and record the events of your day or event. A response paper is something you write to express your views or ideas on a certain subject. Controlled ideas are common in reaction papers. You should give your views on different topics, not just one topic like in a essay.
Diaries are written at the time they occur so they provide information about what happened during those moments. On the other hand, reaction papers are written after the incident has taken place which allows you to think more critically about issues that are important to you.
Furthermore, diaries are private while reaction papers can be read by others so they should be written carefully.
Do not use jargon in your diary entries or reaction papers will not be understood. Also, do not write in block capitals as this is considered poor grammar today.
Finally, diaries are written for yourself and help you to understand yourself better while reaction papers are written for others who may benefit from reading them.
A reply paper responds to the concepts provided by presenting counter-arguments, etc. A critique is advice on how to improve the presentation of your thoughts. It does not have to be followed but it can help in finding better ways to express yourself.
Reactions are responses that focus on whether or not you like something. They can be positive or negative. Critiques are opinions that discuss different aspects of a topic.
For example, if I were to write a reaction paper about Harry Potter then I would say things such as "I hate Harry Potter" or "I love Harry Potter". But if I were to write a critique paper about Harry Potter then I might say things such as "Harry Potter movies are popular because of the action scenes" or "Harry Potter books are good because J.K. Rowling is talented at creating characters who develop over time".
Both reactions and critiques can be formal or informal. Formal reactions and critiques are those that are written up according to a particular format or guideline. Informal reactions and critiques are those that do not follow this format; they can be unstructured papers or even just comments made in conversation.